Transcript of scopes trial the clarence darrow collection. Judge raulston, however, ruled bryans testimony irrelevant and inadmissible. Judge raulston began by expunging the testimony of bryan from the previous day, stating that it can shed no light upon any issues that will be pending before the higher courts trial 305. Bryans last speech published after his death complete transcripts of scopes trial these transcripts come from the worlds most famous court trial. The twocolumnperpage format of the original has not been preserved. By far the most celebrated court case in rhea county and perhaps in all of tennessee history was the case of the state of tennessee vs. The events which took place in dayton, tennessee, during the scorching july of 1925, are clearly the genesis of the playthe collision of bryan and darrow at dayton was dramatic. A 1925 photo of defense lawyer arthur garfield hays reading scientists testimony into. The testimony evoked bryan s only extended speech of the trial. Genesis triumphant and ready for new jousts, july 18, 1925 part three the scopes trial and the culture of the 1920s. Scopes trial civil liberties and civil rights in the.
Raulston feared the floor might collapse and moved the trial outdoors, where about 5,000 people listened to the heated exchanges. Bryans decision to join the prosecution raised the stakes of the trial, in the minds of many supporters of evolution. In the short and long term, how has the united states been impacted by the scopes trial. The most common claim is darrow scored a triumph for academic freedom after john scopes was accused of violating a tennessee law that prohibited the teaching of evolution farrell 2011, p. Bryan why is this phrase so important to the scopes trail. When judge raulston ruled that the testimony of expert witnesses could shed no light on the questions before the jury and should therefore be excluded, who did the defense put on the stand. Bryan was a a leading fundamentalist, traveling widely to warn against the menace of. The transcript excerpts below include some reference to crowd noises. When judge john raulston refused to admit expert testimony on the validity of evolutionary theory, darrow lost his best defense. Another reason for this move may have been a secret visit by sheriff harris and other officials to the judge, urging him to bring the trial to a conclusion as soon as possible in order to avoid injury, for emotions were running high, and both darrow and bryan. Scopes speaks transcript farewell remarks transcript h. William jennings bryan american experience official site pbs.
It was the inevitable conflict of two historical forces. A record of witness testimony, from the record and documents. The stage was thus set for a trial which would prove to be a media circus, with reporters from across the country descending on the small town of 1,900 people. Raulston moved the trial to the courthouse lawn, citing the. I am not afraid now that you will show me anyi have all the information i want to.
This is a readable, witty, informative look at the famous scopes monkey trial of 1925. Scopes, was charged with violating state law by teaching charles darwins theory of evolution. Darrow interrogating prosecutor william jennings bryan during the scopes trial. Scopes, was accused of violating tennessees butler act, which had made it unlawful to teach human evolution in any statefunded school. The legendary confrontation between william jennings bryan and clarence darrow in the scopes monkey trial took place on a hot monday. Tennessee evolution case, which claimed to be a complete stenographic record. Court strikes bryans testimony transcript jury reaches a verdict. This page contains instructional material about theclosing statement by william jennings bryan in the trial of john scopes. Milton, president and editor of the chattanooga news, who made the speech public on july 28. The trial of john scopes is perhaps the most famous case in american legal history.
The defendant, john thomas scopes, was a high school coach and substitute teacher who had been charged with violating the butler act by teaching the theory of evolution in his classes. The true story of the scopes trial by marvin olasky. The scopes trial part 9 bryan and darrow duel in the shade. A record of witness testimony, from the record and documents of the scopes trial, 1925. There was no reason to suppose that he would treat bryan s testimony any differently, and he didnt. Scopes trial, also called the monkey trial, highly publicized trial that took place july 1021, 1925, during which a dayton, tennessee, highschool teacher, john t. Scopes monkey trial 1925 complete trial transcripts blog, highlights, history of science, scopes trial shortly after the conclusion of the 1925 scopes monkey trial officially, the case of state of tennessee versus john thomas scopes, the national book company cincinnati, ohio published transcripts of the trial. Darrows attempt to destroy bryan s personal credibility likewise could do nothing to alter the outcome of the trial in any legal sense. A brief history with documents is an excellent modern counterpart to sheldon norman grebsteins monkey trial. We think there are other questions involved, and we should want to take mr. It was held in the rhea county courthouse, dayton tennessee.
I recall my grandmother, who was born in 1912, talking about her memories of the trial, moran said. The scopes trial, also known as the scopes monkey trial, was the 1925 prosecution of science teacher john scopes for teaching evolution in. Henry fairfield osborn, president of the american museum of natural history and arguably americas most prominent evolutionist, declared, william jennings bryan is the man on trial. Bryan college apparently sells books related to the scopes trial. Bryan offered the closing statement to bryan s friend george f. William jennings bryan stepped off the train at dayton in july of 1925, ready to fight for a righteous cause. With no other proof or witnesses to offer, the defense gave up. In the spring of 1925, he walked into his classroom and read, from daytons tennesseeapproved textbook hunters civic biology, part of a chapter on the evolution of humankind and darwins theory of natural selection. Bryan says as a witness would not be very valuable.
The american controversy over creation and evolution by edward j. Darrow has is to slur at the bible, but i will answer his question. Eighty years ago, in july 1925, the mixture of religion, science and the public schools caught fire in dayton, tenn. There were no closing arguments made at the trials conclusion. William jennings bryan and the scopes trial was a tragedy. The testimony evoked bryans only extended speech of the trial. Genesis triumphant and ready for new jousts, july 18, 1925. Scopes taught what these children said he taught, we recognize what mr. Darrows questioning on the stand in the scopes trial today follows. Mencken, who covered the scopes trial, transformed himself into a sort of fundamentalist pope. Clarence darrows examination of william jennings bryan at the 1925 scopes trial.
William jennings bryan on the witness stand on day seven of the scopes trial, july 20, 1925. The scopes trial, formally known as the state of tennessee v. The banter began before bryan ever got on the stand. Scopes trial civil liberties and civil rights in the united. Do you think it was obvious that the prosecution would win from the beginning. By 1925, bryan and his followers had succeeded in getting legislation introduced in fifteen states to ban the teaching of evolution.
Events leading up to the scopes trial two sides prepare for trial the scopes trial begins fireworks in the courtroom bryan and malone cross swords an historic duel, a verdict reached the battle continues legacy of the scopes monkey trial biographies. Scopes trial book revisits landmark collision of science. Clarence darrows examination of william jennings bryan at. A 1925 photo of defense lawyer arthur garfield hays reading scientists testimony into the record, near a read your bible sign. The scopes trial sometimes referred to as the scopes monkey trial was a 1925 legal case which argued whether human evolution could be taught in public. Clarence darrow questioned william jennings bryan on the 7thnext to lastday of the scopes monkey trial, producing some of the most hilarious banter ever to grace a courtroom the banter began before bryan ever got on the stand. William jennings bryan testifies at the scopes trial. Bryan i would want to hear expert testimony on that. Linder darrow questions bryan during the scopes trial july 20, 1925smithsonian.
The scopes trial, 2nd edition macmillan learning for. John thomas scopes and commonly referred to as the scopes monkey trial, was an american legal case in july 1925 in which a high school teacher, john t. Aug 21, 2019 the scopes monkey trial official name is state of tennessee v john thomas scopes began on july 10, 1925, in dayton, tennessee. The trial took place over a tennessee law that banned the teaching of human evolution in public schools. An excerpt from maynard mayo metcalfs book showing an illustrated outline of his theory of organic evolution, 1906.
William jennings bryans closing statement in the trial of john scopes. The primary members of the prosecution team were tom stewart attorney general, william jennings bryan, and bryan s son. Scopes, a science teacher and football coach in dayton, tennessee. Scopes monkey trial 1925 complete trial transcripts professor. On the eighth and final day of the trial, june 21, 1925, the court struck bryan s testimony, and of course, scopes is found guilty. Legendary defense lawyer clarence darrow faces off against william jennings bryan in the dayton, tennessee trial of schoolteacher john scopes. The scopes trial, 1st edition macmillan learning for. The scopes trial and americas continuing debate over science and religion focuses on the scopes trial, also known as the monkey trial, which happened in dayton, tennessee in the summer of 1925.
In the summer of 1925, a young schoolteacher named john scopes stood trial in dayton, tennessee, for violating the state law against the teaching of evolution. Scopes himself played a rather small role in the case. The words he kept the faith are inscribed on his tombstone. Bryan mocked metcalfs exposition of the theory of evolution, complaining that the evolutionists had man descending not even from american monkeys, but old world monkeys. William jennings bryans closing statement in the trial of john.
In response to the announcement that bryan would be attending the trial, renowned lawyer and committed agnostic clarence darrow volunteered to serve on scopes defense team. The truths and untruths about one of the trials of the. The scopes monkey trial is perhaps one of the critical events of this controversy and one of the landmark legal decisions of the twentieth century. On thursday july 16, 1925, the focus of the trial turned to whether or not the testimony of scientists would be admitted into evidence. John scopes and his father sitting on the porch at baileys boarding house, 1925, looking back at tennessee collection.
John thomas scopes in 1960, which was the first attempt to provide excerpts from the trial transcript with other historical documents that allow contemporary scholars to get a sense for what it. William jennings bryans closing statement in the trial of. John scopes monkey trial the woodstock whispererjim shelley. Scientific american is the essential guide to the most aweinspiring advances in science and technology, explaining how they change our. Bryan s testimony climax of scopes trial 0 dayton, tenn. Did this make a difference to the outcome of the trial. Toward the end of the trial, darrow put bryan on the stand to give expert testimony on the bible. Bryans testimony climax of scopes trial upi archives. Defendant john scopes 19001970 was a football coach and substitute teacher who was talked into challenging the law by local businessmen and hed once attended school in bryan s birthplace of salem, illinios. His arrest soon followed, and a trial date was set. Bryan and darrow give their final remarks, and the section.
A preliminary hearing on may 9, 1925, officially held scopes for trial by the grand jury, though released him and didnt require him to post bond. The new york times, for example, considered bryans testimony an absurdly pathetic performanceolasky 17. Bryan as a witness, and, of course, the only question here is whether mr. Scopes, charged with violating the butler act, which prohibited the teaching of evolution in tennessee public schools. Raulston determined that expert testimony from scientists would be inadmissible. Before ruling the prosecutions evidence, judge raulston decided to hear some of dr. Toward the end of the trial, darrow put bryan on the stand to give expert testimony on the the transcript excerpts below include some reference to crowd noises. Mar 21, 2021 the scopes trial took eight days to litigate but only nine minutes for the jury to decide. Text of the closingstatement of williamjennings bryan at the trial of john. Scopes trial, also called the monkey trial, highly publicized trial that took place july 1021, 1925, during which a dayton, tennessee, highschool teacher.
William jennings bryans proposed address in the scopes trial, 1925 posthumously published this version of bryans proposed address differs from the published version in that the section titles have been numbered and paragraph numbers have been added. Complete trial transcripts from 1925 scopes money trial john thomas scopes v. With hundreds of people standing in the back of the courtroom, judge john t. The creationists and intelligent design theorists are a farce. John thomas scopes and commonly referred to as the scopes monkey trial, was an american. The interrogation of william jennings bryan william jennings bryan testifies at the scopes trial clarence darrow questioned william jennings bryan on the 7thnext to lastday of the scopes monkey trial, producing some of the most hilarious banter ever to grace a courtroom.
Scopes trial 1925 university of minnesota law school. Hegel remarks somewhere that all great, worldhistorical facts and personages occur, as it were, twice. Tennessee schoolteacher john scopes brought the question of teaching evolution in schools to every dinner table, and it remains an essential topic in any course on american history, the history of education, and religious history. The prosecution objected, arguing that the testimony was irrelevant to scopes guilt or innocence under the statute. For my research paper on the scopes monkey trial, i intend to compare the ideas and beliefs of the politician william jennings bryan with the ideas and beliefs of fictional. The butler act in 1859 english naturalist charles darwin published on the origin of species by means of natural selection, a collection of scientific evidence that supported the theory of evolution. Jul 05, 2005 a famous orator, william jennings bryan was 65 when he joined the prosecution team in the scopes trial. Raulston feared the floor might collapse and moved the trial outdoors, where about 5,000 people listened to the heated exchanges between bryan and darrow. The trials climax came on july 20, when darrow called on bryan to testify as an expert witness for the prosecution on the bible. Jun, 2010 as all the world knows, bryans greatest i. Court strikes bryan s testimony transcript jury reaches a verdict. The scopes trial, commonly referred to as the scopes evolution trial or the scopes monkey trial, began on july 10th, 1925. The first historian to write a book length account of the scopes trial, ray ginger of brandeis university, summed up the darrow bryan confrontation by saying, darrows manhandling of bryan had a shattering impact ginger 152.
815 1614 1654 1662 855 194 812 660 1485 524 1324 309 567 320 1460 914 238 1379 1504 111 1656 248